Penalty Shootouts: The Rules, the Order, and the Mind Games
The Coin Toss and the Setup
Image: Rules & Regulations 📐📐📐, by allenhimself, CC BY 2.0
The shootout begins at the centre circle, not the penalty area. The referee calls the two captains over, tosses a coin, and the winner picks which goal the kicks will be taken at: the end, and with it the crowd behind it. Under the Laws of the Game, published by IFAB, that choice does not automatically bring the first kick with it. Who kicks first is settled either by a second toss or by the same toss in competitions that combine both decisions, so check the competition rules before assuming. The order alternates from there.
Only players on the field at the final whistle, plus eligible substitutes, may take part. If one side has fewer players, whether through a red card or an injury that could not be replaced, both teams cut to the same number, and the captain of the short side names who drops out of the list.
Then the mechanics. The taker puts the ball on the spot, the referee's whistle releases the kick, and the goalkeeper must have part of one foot on or in line with the goal line at the moment the ball is struck.
The list of takers is fixed before the first kick and handed to the referee. It contains players on the pitch at the end of the match and substitutes named on the team sheet, though competitions can restrict this further: some cup rules allow only the players who finished the game plus a set number of subs, others open it to the full squad. A player who has been sent off cannot be on it.
The equal-numbers rule is where it gets fiddly. If a team finishes with ten men, both lists trim to ten, and the captain of the full side decides who is left out. That player is then unavailable for the whole shootout, not just one kick. Suppose the ten-man side's fifth listed taker is the one dropped: the order runs four kicks each before sudden death, and the short side's weaker takers move up a place.
A goalkeeper injured during the shootout can be replaced by a named substitute if the competition permits it, and the replacement inherits the same restrictions on movement.
Five Kicks, Sudden Death, and the ABBA Trial
Each team takes up to five kicks, alternating, with Team A listed first and Team B answering. The order within a team is fixed at the start and cannot be shuffled once play begins.
The shootout stops as soon as one side cannot be caught. If Team A has scored three and Team B has taken three and missed all three, the contest is over at 3-0 — there is no prospect of B drawing level, so the remaining kicks are not taken. Referees and captains do the arithmetic; players often do not realise it is finished until the whistle goes.
If the scores are level after five rounds each, sudden death begins. One kick per team per round, still alternating, until a round produces a goal for one side and a miss or save for the other. The tally from the first five rounds carries over, so a shootout that stood at 4-4 goes into sudden death at 4-4 and the next converted kick, if matched by the other team, simply moves it to 5-5.
Both kicks in a round are taken before the outcome is known. A team cannot win on the strength of its own kick alone.
The ABBA sequence ran A-B-B-A-A-B. Team A kicked first, then Team B twice, then A twice, then B, and so on. The idea was to remove the structural advantage of always leading: under the standard format the team kicking second trails after every round unless it equalises, and research into tennis tiebreaks suggested that pattern carried a psychological cost. IFAB approved trials around 2017-18 and several competitions ran them.
The experiment did not last. Players and officials found the order hard to track in the moment, and broadcasters had to explain a sequence that ran against decades of habit. Graphics showing the tally became harder to read at a glance, because the two columns no longer advanced in step. Evidence that ABBA actually reduced the first-kicker advantage was also limited, and the trials were too small to settle the question.
IFAB dropped the trial, and the Laws returned to the standard alternating order, which remains in place. The episode is a reminder that a rule can be logically sound and still fail on usability.
- The Coin Toss decides which goal the kicks are taken at; the winner also chooses whether to kick first or second.
- Kicks alternate between the teams, Team A then Team B, for up to five rounds with one kick each per round.
- The shootout ends early once one team cannot be caught, so a 3-0 lead after three rounds each finishes it.
- Sudden Death follows five level rounds: one kick each, alternating, until one team scores and the other fails to.
- Rebounds and follow-ups are not allowed. The kick is complete once the ball stops, leaves play, or the keeper saves it.
How to Read a Shootout Scoreboard
Image: Rules & Regulations 📐📐📐, by allenhimself, CC BY 2.0
The match score stays exactly as it finished after extra time. A shootout decides who advances, not what the game ended 1-1, and the tally sits in brackets beside it: 1-1 (4-3 on penalties). FIFA's official records and most broadcasters shorten that to "pens" or "PSO" (penalty shootout), so the same result may appear as 1-1 (4-3 pens) or 1-1 PSO 4-3.
Those kicks never enter the match score, and they do not count in player goal tallies. A player who converts in a shootout does not add to his season total, which is why a 4-3 on penalties never appears in a league table or a top scorer list.
Some apps break the shootout onto its own line, so a fixture listed as "4-3" underneath the 1-1 can read like a different match. It isn't. Treat the bracketed figure as the shootout only, and the score above it as the result the game actually finished with.
Under each team name, broadcasts place a row of small markers: a green tick for a converted kick, a red cross for one missed or saved, and a grey dot for a kick not yet taken. Once a team has used its Five Kicks, the row stops growing only if the shootout ends. In Sudden Death the graphic extends past five markers, adding a fresh pair for each round until the tie breaks.
On the tally, a saved kick and a kick struck wide or over look identical: both are a red cross. The distinction lives in the commentary, where the goalkeeper gets credit for the save, and often in a replay. If you glance away and see only the marker, you know the kick failed but not why.
The row updates after every kick, so at any moment you can count the ticks on each side and see who leads or who must score to stay alive. A team with fewer ticks and one grey dot still to come is not out of it. Watch the grey markers, not just the coloured ones.
Pressure, Keepers, and the Small Rules
Image: Spinning House Rules & Regulations, by Historyworks Photography, CC BY 2.0
Coaches front-load the list because the fifth kick often never happens. A reliable first taker settles nerves and puts a number on the board, while a missed fifth kick only matters if the shootout reaches it. The counter-argument, that the fifth slot should go to the calmest player, has been tested repeatedly at World Cups and European Championships without producing a clear pattern: shootouts that end 3-1 in four rounds make the fifth taker irrelevant, and those that go to five often hinge on who was left standing rather than who was picked first.
Keepers work the edges of the law. Some hold the ball, some talk, some gesture at the corner they intend to dive towards. All of it is legal as long as part of one foot is on or level with the line when the ball is struck. Step clearly off it, or let a teammate encroach into the area, and the referee can order a retake if the kick is scored. The taker has limits too: feinting during the run-up is allowed, but stopping at the end of it to see where the keeper goes is not.
Next time a match goes to penalties, watch The Coin Toss before anything else. It tells you who kicks first, and under IFAB rules the winner also chooses that, though some competitions have experimented with fixed orders. Read the bracketed shootout score rather than the match score: a 1-1 result with (4-3 on penalties) beside it is a shootout decided, not a game won. Then track the kick markers on the Shootout Scoreboard as they fill. In Sudden Death the markers reset the picture entirely, since each side now takes one kick and the first miss that is not matched ends it.
Tournament regulations can tighten or alter the procedure, so treat the Laws of the Game as the baseline and the competition's own rules as the final word on anything from squad eligibility to kick order. For a confirmed result, check the official match report, which logs every kick and every save. The next major tournament will produce at least one shootout that turns on a single decision by a keeper or an official, and now you will know where to look.