Penalty Shootouts: The Rules, the Pressure, and the Statistics
How a Penalty Shootout Actually Works
A shootout is only ever a last resort. In knockout competition, the score must still be level after 90 minutes and, where the format allows it, 30 minutes of extra time. Only then does the referee call both captains to the centre circle. The coin toss is simple: the winner chooses whether to take the first kick or the second, while the referee decides which goal all the kicks will be taken at, usually to avoid sunlight, a poor pitch surface or provocation from the crowd behind it.
From there the format is fixed. Teams alternate, kick for kick, five each. Whoever has scored more after those ten kicks wins. The order is not a free-for-all: each team lists its five takers, and every player who kicks must be eligible at the moment the kick is taken.
The shootout can also end before ten kicks are used. If a team's lead becomes mathematically uncatchable, the referee stops it there. Go 3-0 up after three rounds each and the contest is over, because your opponent has only two kicks left.
If the score is still level after five kicks each, the shootout moves to sudden death. Teams take one kick each in turn, and the first side to lead after an equal number of kicks wins. The same order carries on from the first five, so the sixth kicker is whoever was listed sixth, and so on. One restriction holds throughout: every eligible player in the squad, including the goalkeeper, must take a kick before anyone can go again. That rule has decided more than one marathon, when a shootout runs deep enough to reach the defenders and the bench.
FIFA has tinkered with the sequence only once in recent memory. It trialled the ABBA order, where one team kicks first, the other kicks twice, then the first team kicks twice, and in 2017 reverted to the traditional alternating format after the trial produced no clear improvement.
What the Goalkeeper Can and Cannot Do
The rule is narrow and often misquoted. At the moment the ball is kicked, the goalkeeper must have at least part of one foot touching the goal line, or in line with it. Stepping forward before the kick is an offence; the keeper may not move off the line early, though the 2019 law clarification confirmed they can shuffle sideways along it, and the line itself extends to the goal net.
Enforcement changed with video review. A save that once stood can now be overturned if the replay shows both feet ahead of the line, and the kick is retaken. The 2019 Women's World Cup gave the clearest example: Scotland led Argentina 3-0, Argentina were awarded a late penalty, goalkeeper Lee Alexander saved it, VAR showed she had left her line, and Florencia Bonsegundo scored the retake. The match finished 3-3 and Scotland went out. Keepers now routinely hold a foot on the paint until contact, because the camera is watching the line as closely as they are.
- Remember that only players on the field at the final whistle may take kicks; teams also reduce to equal numbers if one side has fewer eligible players.
- Know that a goalkeeper can be replaced before the shootout starts, provided the team has a substitution left and the referee is told.
- Accept that a save or a miss ends that attempt at once; there is no rebound, follow-up or second bite at the ball.
- Keep every eligible player outside the centre circle while kicks are taken, with only the taker and the two keepers involved.
- Leave the choice of goal to the referee, who picks the end, usually after a pitch inspection and sometimes a coin toss.
The Numbers Behind the Nerve
The chart above reflects a pattern that researchers have returned to repeatedly: the shootout is a worse scoring environment than open play. Across major competitions, the average conversion rate in shootouts sits somewhere around 70 to 75 percent, while in-match penalties tend to land a little higher, roughly 75 to 80 percent. The gap is not enormous, but it is consistent.
Kicking order matters too. Analysis of large samples from European leagues and international tournaments suggests conversion falls for later kicks, when the scoreline is tighter and the walk from the centre circle feels longer. Sudden-death attempts convert at a lower rate again than the first five. The team that kicks first also holds a modest edge, with several studies putting its win rate near 60 percent, a finding that prompted FIFA to trial the ABBA sequence before abandoning it.
Treat these as approximate figures drawn from a body of research rather than fixed laws. Samples vary, competition levels differ, and the definition of pressure is hard to pin down. What the numbers do support is the intuition every player describes: the further a shootout goes, the harder the kick becomes.
Commentary loves the fifth penalty. It gets the slow walk, the close-up, the caption about a career resting on one strike. The data is less romantic. Geir Jordet's work on penalty behaviour found that the first kick carries its own weight, and sudden-death attempts sit under pressure at least as heavy as kick five. The fifth taker is often a team's best, and by then the shootout may already be settled.
What separates takers is rarely nerve in the abstract. Jordet's analysis of major tournaments showed that players who maintained a consistent routine and took the ball quickly after the whistle converted more often. Those who stalled, waited on the referee or let the goalkeeper dictate the moment missed more. The old term for the failure is choking: skill that exists in training but does not survive the stakes.
Roberto Baggio in 1994 and Gareth Southgate in 1996 are remembered for misses, but both had taken penalties before and would again. The kick is not a verdict on character. It is a rehearsed action performed under a condition few rehearsals can reproduce.
Why the Shootout Still Divides Opinion
The case against is easy to state: a shootout can undo two hours of superior football. A side that dominated possession, hit the post twice and defended with discipline goes out because a defender who never takes penalties in open play clips the bar. Critics call it a lottery, and the numbers give them something to work with, since conversion sits well below what teams manage from the spot during normal play.
The defence rests on the opposite claim: that a penalty is a skill, not a coin toss. Composure, routine and a goalkeeper's research all shape outcomes, and the same nations and the same takers keep succeeding. The drama argument is real too. Few moments in sport gather a crowd the way a shootout does.
Alternatives have been floated and quietly dropped. Counting corners or shots on target was proposed as a fairer tiebreak and rejected as arbitrary. Replays were abandoned as impractical. Even ABBA, designed to remove the advantage of kicking first, was trialled and then shelved in 2017 after FIFA found it confused players and officials more than it helped.
Start with the coin toss. The winner chooses whether to kick first or pick the end, and that second choice matters more than most fans realise: wind, sun, and a wall of noise behind the goal all shift the odds. Watch the referee's signal so you know which came first.
Then keep your eyes on the goalkeeper's feet at the moment of contact. Part of one foot must be on or in line with the goal line, and with VAR in place that detail gets checked. Notice the order of takers too. Geir Jordet's research suggests the first kick carries unusual weight, so a manager who sends out a nervous youngster early is making a statement. And track the early-stoppage rule: once a team cannot be caught, the remaining kicks are cancelled. That is why a shootout sometimes ends at 3-1 with two penalties still on the list.
Knowing these details turns a blur of noise into a sequence you can read. The official Laws of the Game, published by FIFA, have the exact wording if you want the full text.